Foundations in Philosophy of Science  Carl Hoefer

     

  

Second course

 

Department

Lògica, Història i Filosofia de la Ciència

Universitat de Barcelona

 

Language

English

 

Objectives

This course aims at providing an in-depth introduction to two fundamental topics in the philosophy of science:  causation, and laws of nature.  We will cover some classic papers on causation and laws, as well as some recent publications.

  

Structure  and  Content

 

Part 1:  Causality

 

Classic texts:  Anscombe. "Causation and Determination",  Lewis, "Causation" (1973)

Causation & counterfactuals:  Readings from Causation and Counterfactuals by:

Ned Hall

David Lewis

Helen Beebee

Chris Hitchcock

Tim Maudlin

Causation and Intervention: 

J. Woodward

J. Bogen

 

Part 2: Laws of Nature

 

Classic texts:  Dretske, "What Is a Law of Nature?", van Fraassen, Laws and Symmetry ch. 2,  Lewis, excerpt from Counterfactuals

Recent defense:  Tim Maudlin, excerpts from The Metaphysics Within Physics  

Methodology

Lectures with time devoted to discussion. We will devote approximately seven of the lectures to the first part of the course and five to the second lectures to the second.

  

Evaluation

Two medium-length essays (one for each main part of the course). Due date for the both essays will be announced in class.

 

Bibliography 

           

Many classic papers can be found in this collection:

SOSA & TOOLEY, ed.s, Causation (Oxford University Press, 1993).

 

Essential classic sources on causation include:

Hume  Treatise, Book I, ch. 3, sections 1-6, 11, 12, 14 & 15

Russell "On the Notion of Cause", Mysticism and Logic

Anscombe  "Causality and Determination" in Sosa & Tooley

Mackie   "Causes and Conditions"  in Sosa & Tooley

Lewis (1973)  "Causation", J. Philosophy, rep. in Philosophical Papers v. II (1986), with postscripts; also in Sosa & Tooley

 

 

Further books used in readings:

 

John Collins, Ned Hall , L.A. Paul (Editors),Causation and Counterfactuals (Bradford Books, 2004) 

N. Cartwright, The Dappled World (Cambridge U. Press, 1999)

T. Maudlin, The Metaphysics Within Physics (OUP, 2007)

 

The reading list is an initial proposal, subject to change as needed during the course. Specific readings will be assigned for each class.