Bechly, G. 1999.- Phylogeny and systematics
of fossil dragonflies (Insecta: Odonatoptera) with special reference to
some Mesozoic outcrops. - PhD thesis, Eberhard-Karls-University Tübingen.
x + 755 pp.; Tübingen.
Email: bechly@gmx.de
The first
section of this thesis mainly contains alpha-taxonomical contributions
to the knowledge of fossil odonates from several outcrops.
* Triassic
odonates: the odonate fauna of the Upper Triassic
of Bergamo is revised. A new genus and species Italomyrmeleon bergomensis
is described as first Protomyrmeleontidae from the Triassic of Europe.
A tiny fossil odonate which belongs to a new genus and species is described
but not named because it is a poorly preserved specimen. Italophlebia
gervasuttii is redescribed and a new species of the same genus, Italophlebia
paganoniae, is described. The phylogenetic position of Italophlebia
is discussed and the genus is shown to be one of the oldest known stemgroup
representatives of Anisoptera, and is therefore transferred from Zygoptera
- Hemiphlebioidea to "Anisozygoptera" - Isophlebioptera. The taxonomy of
all fossil odonates from other Triassic localities is discussed, and several
new positions and new synonymies are suggested. Reisia nana is described
as new species from France. Reisia (= Triadotypus) and Triassologus
are both transferred from "Protodonata" to Triadophlebioptera, so that
there are no Triassic protodonates known any longer. Thuringopteryx
gimmi is transferred from "Protodonata" to Palaeodictyoptera, as
the first known Triassic representative of this group.
* Anisoptera from
the Upper Jurassic of Germany: The dragonfly
genus Urogomphus from the Upper Jurassic of Germany is revised and
its position in Aeschnidiidae is confirmed. Urogomphus giganteus
and U. eximius are redescribed, and a lectotype for U. eximius
is designated. Lithoaeschnidium viohli is considered as a
synonym of U. eximius.
A new species Urogomphus nusplingensis is described from
the Upper Jurassic limestones of Nusplingen, while the 20 other known specimens
of this genus have been found in the Solnhofen Lithographic Limestone.
Urogomphus abscissus is considered as conspecific with Bergeriaeschnidia
inexpectata, and the holotype of the latter species is designated
as neotype of U. abscissus, so that its valid name is now Bergeriaeschnidia
abscissa. The phylogenetic position of Urogomphus and Aeschnidiidae
is discussed, and an explanation for the extinction of Aeschnidiidae, Mesozoic
anisozygopteres, and Palaeozoic protodonates is proposed.
Protolindenia wittei
and the genus Aeschnogomphus from the Upper Jurassic of Germany,
are revised. Aeschnogomphus buchi is recognized as valid
name for Aeschnogomphus charpentieri. Protolindenia,
formerly considered to be a gomphid, is transferred to Petalurida, as most
basal member of the stemgroup of Petaluridae. Aeschnogomphus, formerly
considered to be a Cordulegastridae or Gomphidae, is transferred to Aktassiidae
in Petalurida.
The type species of
the genus Mesuropetala is redescribed, and Mesuropetala muensteri
is considered as its valid name instead of Mesuropetala koehleri.
The genus Aeschnopsis is transferred to Mesuropetalidae, and two
new species, Aeschnopsis perkinsi and A. tischlingeri
are described from the Solnhofen Lithographic Limestone. Cymatophlebia
longialata is redescribed. Curious (autapomorphic) structures on the
male abdomen of Cymatophlebia spp. are described in detail and their
function is discussed. Four new species of the genus Cymatophlebia
are described: Cymatophlebia kuempeli and Cymatophlebia pumilio
from the Solnhofen Lithographic Limestone, and Cymatophlebia suevica
and Cymatophlebia herrlenae from the Malm beta of the Swabian Alb.
The two holotype specimens of Cymatophlebia suevica and Cymatophlebia
herrlenae represent the oldest known crowngroup representatives of
Anisoptera, and the first fossil insect remains known from the Malm beta
of the Swabian Alb. With an estimated wing span of more than 22 cm, Cymatophlebia
suevica seems to represent the biggest Anisoptera and even the biggest
crowngroup Odonata known at all. A new genus Eumorbaeschna with
the type species "Cymatophlebia" jurassica (Carpenter, 1932)
is proposed as "replacement" name for the aeshnid described by Needham
(1907) under the incorrect name "Morbaeschna muensteri" because
of a misidentified type species. The genus Morbaeschna is synonymized
with the genus Mesuropetala.
The adult fossil dragonflies
from the Lower Cretaceous of Mongolia that were previously attributed to
the species Sona nectes (Sonidae) are classified as new taxon Proterogomphus
krauseorum in a new family Proterogomphidae within the monophylum Gomphides.
A new species Proterogomphus renateae is described from the Solnhofen
Lithographic Limestone. The status of the alleged hemeroscopid larvae is
discussed and they are preliminarily transferred as new (unnamed) species
to Sonidae, which is restricted to the referring fossil larvae that have
to be regarded as larval Aeschnidiidae.
Nannogomphus bavaricus
from the Solnhofen Lithographic Limestone is redescribed. The phylogenetic
affinities of Nannogomphus within Anisoptera are discussed. The
alleged gomphid affinities are dismissed as based on symplesiomorphies
and convergences. Nannogomphus is classified in a new family Nannogomphidae,
which is regarded as most basal representative of Brachystigmata. This
new family probably also includes a new genus with two new species, Prohemeroscopus
jurassicus and P. kuehnapfeli, that are described from the same
layers.
A new genus and species
Juracordulia schiemenzi is described from the Solnhofen Lithographic
Limestone. The analysis of the wing venation reveals that this new dragonfly
species belongs to the stemgroup of Eurypalpida (Libelluloidea auct.).
It is the first certain record of Eurypalpida from this locality and the
first Jurassic and thus oldest record of this taxon at all.
* New Anisoptera
from the Lower Cretaceous of China: a new
genus and species Progobiaeshna liaoningensis is described from
the Lower Cretaceous of China in a new family Progobiaeshnidae, which is
regarded as sistergroup of Aeshnida within the new higher taxa Aeshnomorpha
- Panaeshnida. Gobiaeshna occulta is preliminarily attributed to
this new family, too.
* Odonata from the
Lower Cretaceous of Brazil: an overview of
the fossil odonate fauna of the Crato Formation from the Lower Cretaceous
of Brazil is given. Currently 384 specimens (264 adults and 120 larvae)
in 12 families and 34 species are known to science. More than half of the
adult and larval fossil odonates belong to the clade Gomphides, especially
to the Cordulagomphinae which supports the hypothesis of an allochthonous
origin of the aquatic insects. The new genus and species Araripeliupanshania
annesuseae is described in Mesuropetaloidea - Liupanshaniidae, and
represents the first New World record of this group. Two new genera and
three new species, Paramorbaeschna araripensis, Progomphaeschnaoides
ursulae, and Progomphaeschnaoides staniczeki, are described
within Neoaeshnida - Gomphaeschnidae in a new subfamily Gomphaeschnaoidinae.
In the same group three further new species, Gomphaeschnaoides magnus,
Gomphaeschnaoides petersi, and Gomphaeschnaoides betoreti
are described, together with a redescription of the type species Gomphaeschnaoides
obliquus, including its previously unknown forewings and body. Six
further new taxa are described: Araripegomphus andreneli (Araripegomphidae),
Cordulagomphus (Procordulagomphus) senckenbergi (Proterogomphidae
- Cordulagomphinae), Araripephlebia mirabilis (Araripephlebiidae),
Cratocordulia borschukewitzi (Araripelibellulidae), Cretarchistigma
essweini (Zygoptera incertae sedis), and Parahemiphlebia mickoleiti
(Hemiphlebiidae). With a wing length of only 9 mm the latter new species
represents one of the smallest odonates of all times. Araripephlebia
mirabilis is classified in a new family Araripephlebiidae that probably
represents the sistergroup of Valdicorduliidae. A still unnamed new genus
and species represents the first fossil record and the first New World
record for Chlorogomphida. Four further new species are illustrated and
discussed, but not yet named. The phylogenetic relationship of several
known species is discussed, and some diagnoses are amended or corrected.
Giant dragonfly larvae of up to 70 mm length are described, regarded as
older stages of Nothomacromia sensibilis, and considered as larval
Aeschnidiidae. The position of Araripegomphidae in the stemgroup of Gomphides
rather than Eurypalpida (= Libelluloidea auct.) is advocated (contra Lohmann,
1996). The former genus Procordulagomphus is down-ranked to a subgenus
of Cordulagomphus. "Cordulagomphus" santanensis is
recognized as earwig and thus transferred from Odonata - Cordulagomphinae
to Dermaptera incertae sedis. The taphonomy of the Crato limestones
is discussed and an origin in a brackish lagoon without autochthonous insects
is advocated. A comparison with the odonate fauna of the Upper Jurassic
Lithographic Limestones of Solnhofen reveals several remarkable differences.
Because of the absence of typical Mesozoic odonate groups, such as anisozygopteres,
Archizygoptera and Steleopteridae, as well as the presence of extant families
of Zygoptera, the odonate fauna of the Crato Formation appears to be already
significantly more advanced.
* Odonata from amber
and fossil Epallagidae: Litheuphaea ludwigi
is described as new species and first representative of Epallagidae from
Baltic amber, and the holotype of Litheuphaea carpenteri is redescribed.
The authorship of
Selys (1853) for the family-group name Euphaeidae is rejected, since the
"légion Euphaea" proposed by Selys is neither a noun in the nominative
plural, nor ending in a latinized suffix. Consequently, the correct family
name must be Epallagidae Needham, 1903, since Euphaeidae were first established
by Jacobson & Bianchi (1905) and thus have to be considered as a junior
subjective synonym. Similarly, all the other "légions" proposed
by Selys are rejected as available family-group taxa, so that the next
available family-group name has to be used, e.g. Heliocharitidae Tillyard
& Fraser, 1939 instead of Dicteriadidae Montgomery, 1959 (nec Selys,
1853). A unique fossil odonate is briefly described, which represents a
damselfly in Baltic amber that is just emerging from the exuvia (probably
Platystictidae or Megapodagrionidae). An annotated new catalogue of all
known odonates in amber is provided, including 70 specimens from Lebanon,
Dominican, Paris, Baltic and Saxonian amber, of which 6 specimens are adult
Anisoptera and 5 specimens are exuviae. A lectotype for Platycnemis
antiqua is designated and illustrated.
The second section
of the thesis contains phylogenetic systematic analyses and conclusions
about the evolution of odonates.
Some theoretical problems
of modern phylogenetic research are discussed, with special consideration
of the issue of character weighting and its implications for the principle
of parsimony. The cladistic paradigm of parsimony is rejected and a broader
concept of phylogenetic parsimony is advocated. Pattern cladism is shown
to be fundamentally different from Hennigian phylogenetic systematics,
and more similar to numerical taxonomy (phenetics).
A set of basic principles
and rules for phylogenetic taxonomy and classification is proposed, including
a new notation for synonymic lists that also considers taxa that are synonymous
in content but no synonyms according to the current rules of zoological
nomenclature.
Based on a very comprehensive
"manual" phylogenetic analysis, a reclassification of all higher taxa of
fossil and extant odonates above the genus-group level is introduced. For
all proposed monophyla a complete list of all known autapomorphies (including
wing venational characters, as well as all other available evidence, e.g.
body anatomy, larval morphology, molecular data, behaviour, etc.), a recommended
usage, and a complete synonymy is provided. Numerous new higher taxa are
described (see list below). The most important results include the confirmation
of the sistergroup relationship of Ephemeroptera and Odonatoptera (monophyly
of Palaeoptera), the demonstration of monophyly of Zygoptera (contra Fraser,
1954, 1957; Hennig, 1969, 1981; Pfau, 1986, 1991; Zessin, 1991; Trueman,
1991, 1996; Nel et al., 1993), the identification of Tarsophlebiidae as
fossil sistergroup of crowngroup Odonata, the identification of the basal
splitting events in Anisoptera with Petalurida being recognized as most
basal clade, as well as a revised position of Epiophlebiidae within the
"anisozygopteroid" grade. Only the ingroup relationships within extant
Coenagrionidae, Gomphidae and Libellulidae could not be completely resolved
yet. The main differences of the proposed system to other recently proposed
phylogenetic systems of Odonata (Carle, 1995, 1996; Trueman, 1996; Lohmann,
1996) are discussed.
At the example of
Aeshnoptera, it is demonstrated that many derived wing venational characters
have a very incongruent pattern, which implies either multiple convergent
gains, or reductions, of the referring characters. The problem of this
high level of homoplasy for the phylogenetic reconstructions is discussed.
A numerical cladistic
parsimony analysis of the major clades of Anisoptera confirmed the results
of the "manual" phylogenetic analysis. Only the phylogenetic position of
Gomphides (incl. Proterogomphidae) could not be correctly resolved, because
of the lack of appropriate wing venational apomorphies. A "manual" phylogenetic
analysis, based on the morphology of extant dragonflies, identifies Petalurida
as sistergroup of all remaining crowngroup Anisoptera. Several important
plesiomorphic features of Petalurida are discussed, and the alleged plesiomorphy
of semi-terrestrial larvae is rejected. A numerical cladistic analysis
and "manual" phylogenetic analysis of all fossil and extant petalurid genera
is provided. Two different scenarios of the historical biogeography of
Petalurida are discussed.
Taxonomy:
This thesis includes
the description of 83 new higher taxa (above the family-group level), 26
new families, 18 new subfamilies, 10 new tribes, 5 new subtribes, 15 new
genera, 1 new subgenus, and 30 new species. Furthermore, there are 80 taxa
stat. nov. (nomina translata), 10 taxa stat. rest., 95 taxa sens.
nov., 73 taxa pos. nov., 27 new synonymies, 3 type designations, and 5
corrected spellings (justified emendations and mandatory changes). Please
note that all listed taxonomical acts are only becoming available and valid
with the referring publications from this PhD thesis (see list below),
which itself has to be regarded as unpublished according to Art. 8 and
9 IRZN.
This thesis is published
in several parts with the following publications:
Bechly,
G. (1996): Morphologische Untersuchungen am
Flügelgeäder der rezenten Libellen und deren Stammgruppenvertreter
(Insecta; Pterygota; Odonata), unter besonderer Berücksichtigung der
Phylogenetischen Systematik und des Grundplanes der *Odonata. - Petalura,
spec. vol. 2: 1-402; Böblingen.
Bechly,
G. (1997): New fossil odonates from the Upper
Triassic of Italy, with a redescription of Italophlebia gervasuttii,
and a reclassification of Triassic dragonflies (Insecta: Odonata). - Rivista
del Museo Civico di Scienze Naturali "Enrico Caffi", 19: 31-70; Bergamo.
Bechly,
G. (1998a): New fossil dragonflies from the
Lower Cretaceous Crato Formation of north-east Brazil (Insecta: Odonata).
- Stuttgarter Beiträge zur Naturkunde (B), 264: 1-66; Stuttgart.
Bechly,
G. (1998b): Phylogenetic Systematics of Odonata.
- [Website on the Internet, new URL: http://members.tripod.de/GBechly/index.htm].
[will be electronically published on CD-ROM: Schorr, M. & Lindeboom,
M. (eds) (2000): Fundamentals of odonatological research. Tübingen]
Bechly,
G. (1998c): Juracordulia schiemenzi
gen. et. sp. nov., eine neue Libelle aus den Solnhofener Plattenkalken
(Insecta: Odonata: Anisoptera). - Archaeopteryx, 16: 29-36; Munich.
Bechly,
G. (1998d): New fossil damselflies from Baltic
amber, with description of a new species, a redescription of Litheuphaea
carpenteri Fraser, and a discussion on the phylogeny of Epallagidae
(Zygoptera: Caloptera). - International Journal of Odonatology (Pantala),
1(1): 33-63; Leiden.
Bechly,
G. (1998e): A revision of the fossil dragonfly
genus Urogomphus, with description of a new species (Insecta: Odonata:
Pananisoptera: Aeschnidiidae). - Stuttgarter Beiträge zur Naturkunde
(B), 270: 1-47; Stuttgart.
Bechly,
G., Brauckmann, C. & Zessin, W. (in prep.):
Neue Erkenntnisse zur Morphologie der ältesten Libellen (Insecta:
Odonatoptera) aus dem Namurium von Hagen-Vorhalle (Deutschland).
Bechly,
G., Nel A. & Martínez-Delclòs, X. (1996):
Redescription of Nannogomphus bavaricus Handlirsch, 1906-1908, from
the Upper Jurassic of Germany, with an analysis of its phylogenetic position
(Odonata: Anisoptera: Gomphidae or Libelluloidea). - Archaeopteryx, 14:
51-66; Munich.
Bechly,
G.,Nel, A., Martínez-Delclòs, X. & Fleck, G. (1998):
Four new dragonfly species from the Upper Jurassic of Germany and the Lower
Cretaceous of Mongolia (Anisoptera: Hemeroscopidae, Sonidae, and Proterogomphidae
fam. nov.). - Odonatologica, 27(2): 149-187; Bilthoven.
Bechly,
G., Nel, A., Martínez-Delclòs, X., Jarzembowski, E.A., Coram,
R., Martill, D.,Fleck, G., Escuillié, F., Wisshak, M.M. & Maisch,M.
(in press): A revision and phylogenetic study
of Mesozoic Aeshnoptera, with description of several new families, genera
and species (Insecta: Odonata: Anisoptera). Neue Paläontologische
Abhandlungen, 4, Dresden.
Nel,
A., Bechly, G., Jarzembowski, E.A. & Martínez-Delclòs,
X. (1998): A revision of the fossil petalurid
dragonflies (Insecta: Odonata: Anisoptera: Petalurida). Paleontologia Lombarda
(N.S.), 10: 1-68, Milano.
|